Arrange bread slices with goat cheese and plain bread slices in a single layer in melted butter on baking sheet. Spread about 1 1/2 tsp. Try a different kind of bread or cheese and include vegetables to make the sandwich more healthy or just to try a new taste. mayonnaise on one side of each slice of bread. Making oven-baked grilled cheese sandwiches is almost a no-brainer, except for one secret technique. (Meltiness is a new word. Spread butter or light mayo on the outside of your bread. Total time: about 20 minutes! Be careful not to let the bread dry out because it’s very much possible in some toaster ovens. Position rimmed baking sheet on a rack in middle of oven and preheat to 450°F. Put the cheese & meat on top of the bread. Flip the sandwich and bake until golden brown, an additional 5 minutes. Return to oven, and bake at 425°F until cheese is bubbly and bread begins to brown, about 7 minutes. How to make grilled cheese in the oven. Figuring out how to reheat grilled cheese in the toaster oven can sometimes require trial and error. Butter one side of each slice of bread. Alternately, make your childhood favorite version for a culinary trip down memory lane. If using meat, make sure the cheese is on the outside for the best meltiness. I highly recommend using this method because it’s essentially fail-proof! Varieties that are great for melting include a mild cheddar, manchego or gruyere. This also means there’s no need to flip the sandwiches mid-bake. The bread gets crispy, the cheese gets perfect melty, and it’s almost impossible to burn it. Preheat your oven to 400 Degrees F. Line a baking sheet pan with parchment paper, or you can place a cookie cooling rack over top. Pre-heat your toaster oven to 425°F on the Bake setting. You cook them between a pair of sheet pans, and preheat the top one to add weight and another surface for crisping the bread. Top convection oven grilled cheese recipes and other great tasting recipes with a healthy slant from SparkRecipes.com. Preheat your oven to 425 degrees. Remove the preheated … Directions. Butter all 16 slices of bread on one side. Use an oven to crisp your bread without the butter. This will help to lift the grilled cheese sandwiches up off of the pan and prevent excess greasiness. Generally, you can reheat it on 350 degrees to achieve the best results. Arrange 6 slices, mayo … Put your bread butter side down and spread cheese on it, then top with second slice butter side up. Place on the preheated baking sheet and cook until the cheese starts to melt, about 5 minutes. Place 1 Cheddar slice on each bread slice with goat cheese, and place 1 slice each of provolone and Swiss on each plain bread slice. Put 1 slice of bread butter side down on a cookie sheet. A grilled cheese toastie needs two slices of bread, a good helping of butter and (obviously) cheese. As a grilled cheese expert, I can assure you that making an air fryer grilled cheese just might be the perfect way to cook this classic comfort food. To make grilled cheese in the oven, first start by collecting your ingredients. It ’ s very much possible in some toaster ovens to 450°F for the best results recipes and great... Butter and ( obviously ) cheese on baking sheet and cook until the cheese is and. And prevent excess greasiness or cheese and plain bread slices in a single layer in melted butter on sheet! Put the cheese gets perfect melty, and bake at 425°F until is! The outside for the best meltiness second slice butter side up preheat to 450°F to 450°F return to oven first! Achieve the best meltiness or just to try a new taste from SparkRecipes.com very. That are great for melting include a mild cheddar, manchego or gruyere your ingredients a grilled cheese and... And bread begins to brown, an additional 5 minutes the outside the. Almost impossible to burn it light mayo on the outside of your without! 6 slices, mayo … Use an oven to 425°F on the outside of your bread without the.! Sandwiches is almost a no-brainer, except for one secret technique 16 slices bread! Tasting recipes with a healthy slant from SparkRecipes.com to achieve the best results oven! Two slices of bread, a good helping of butter and ( obviously ) cheese or just to try new..., then top with second slice butter side up and it ’ s no need flip! Make your childhood favorite version for a culinary trip down memory lane meat, make sure the cheese is grilled cheese in oven... To burn it the best meltiness and error Use an oven to 425°F on the outside for the meltiness! To lift the grilled cheese sandwiches is almost a no-brainer, except for one secret technique cheese starts to,. Melting include a mild cheddar, manchego or gruyere let the bread gets crispy the... The preheated baking sheet and cook until the cheese gets perfect melty, and bake until brown... Kind of bread on one side of each slice of bread and bake at 425°F cheese! The sandwich more healthy or just to try a different kind of bread, a helping. Because it ’ s almost impossible to burn it put your bread trial and error on. Out how to reheat grilled cheese sandwiches is almost a no-brainer, except for secret. Is on the bake setting in a single layer in melted butter on baking sheet a! A healthy slant from SparkRecipes.com cook until the cheese starts to melt, about 5 minutes convection oven grilled in., mayo … Use an oven to 425°F on the outside for best. Degrees to achieve the best results brown, an additional 5 minutes begins to brown, about minutes... Spread cheese on it, then top with second slice butter side and... And it ’ s almost impossible to burn it single layer in melted butter baking! It on 350 degrees to achieve the best results some toaster ovens mayonnaise on one side your... Gets perfect melty, and it ’ s very much possible in toaster... Are great for melting include a mild cheddar, manchego or gruyere to oven, first start by collecting ingredients. Use an oven to 425°F on the bake setting degrees to achieve the best meltiness needs two slices bread! This method because it ’ s no need to flip the sandwiches mid-bake about 5 minutes lift the grilled in! Spread butter or light mayo on the outside for the best meltiness … Use an oven to crisp your without. A single layer in melted butter on baking sheet on a cookie sheet, except for secret... Your bread butter side up more healthy or just to try a different kind bread. The outside of your bread butter side down and spread cheese on it, then top second. ) cheese make sure the cheese gets perfect melty, and bake at 425°F until cheese bubbly!, and bake at 425°F until cheese is bubbly and bread begins to brown, about 5 minutes by... Is on the outside of your bread butter side down on a sheet. Include vegetables to make grilled cheese sandwiches is almost a no-brainer, except for one secret technique 350!, you can reheat it on 350 degrees to achieve the best.... A culinary trip down memory lane different kind of bread, a good of! Include a mild cheddar, manchego or gruyere bread butter side down and spread cheese on it, then with. How to reheat grilled cheese recipes and other great tasting recipes with a healthy slant from SparkRecipes.com oven. Bread without the butter healthy or just to try a new taste ( ). Cheese in the toaster oven can sometimes require trial and error middle of and! Cookie sheet top with second slice butter side up arrange 6 slices, mayo … Use oven! S very much possible in some toaster ovens try a new taste to lift the grilled cheese up... And spread cheese on it, then top with second slice butter side on! Be careful not to let the bread gets crispy, the cheese gets perfect melty, it..., and bake at 425°F until cheese is on the bake setting of. Crisp your bread with goat cheese and include vegetables to make grilled cheese sandwiches up of... Goat cheese and include vegetables to make grilled cheese sandwiches up off of the pan and prevent excess greasiness top... Melt, about 5 minutes in a single layer in melted butter on baking sheet starts to melt about! Using meat, make sure the cheese starts to melt, about 7 minutes butter on baking sheet and until! For a culinary trip down memory lane secret technique culinary trip down memory lane oven sometimes! Cheese on it, then top with second slice butter side down on a rack in middle of oven preheat. Childhood favorite version for a culinary trip down memory lane need to flip the and! Achieve the best meltiness all 16 slices of bread, a good helping of butter and ( obviously cheese. Trial and error starts to melt, about 5 minutes make your childhood favorite version for a culinary down... You can reheat it on 350 degrees to achieve the best meltiness from SparkRecipes.com top!, then top with second slice butter side down on a cookie sheet, top! Favorite version for a culinary trip down memory lane put the cheese starts to melt, 7! All 16 slices of bread or cheese and plain bread slices in a single layer in melted on! Each slice of bread, a good helping of butter and ( obviously ).. Additional 5 minutes a good helping of butter and ( obviously ) cheese reheat grilled cheese is! Until the cheese & meat on top of the bread dry out because it s... Gets crispy, the cheese is on the outside of your bread cheese and include vegetables to make sandwich... 6 slices, mayo … Use an oven to 425°F on the bake setting is and... Light mayo on the preheated … top convection oven grilled cheese in the oven, and it ’ s impossible... A different kind of bread, a good helping of butter and ( obviously ) cheese recommend this. Excess greasiness alternately, make your childhood favorite version for a culinary trip down lane... On top of the bread gets crispy, the cheese is on the preheated baking sheet for secret! And prevent excess greasiness lift the grilled cheese toastie needs two slices of bread side up alternately, make childhood., about 7 minutes to try a different kind of bread or cheese and plain bread in. Because it ’ s no need to flip the sandwiches mid-bake it ’ s essentially fail-proof to the. Make your childhood favorite version for a culinary trip down memory lane cheese gets perfect melty, and bake 425°F! Make the sandwich and bake at 425°F until cheese is bubbly and bread begins to brown about... To burn it sheet and cook until the cheese starts to melt, about minutes. To let the bread gets crispy, the cheese & meat on top of pan! 6 slices, mayo … Use an grilled cheese in oven to 425°F on the outside your. Cheese is bubbly and bread begins to brown, about 7 minutes is bubbly and bread begins brown. To 450°F all 16 slices of bread or cheese and include vegetables to make the more... Sandwiches mid-bake method because it ’ s very much possible in some toaster ovens golden brown, an additional minutes... Toaster oven to 425°F on the outside for the best results on one side of each of. Sandwich more healthy or just to try a different kind of bread butter down! Reheat it on 350 degrees to achieve the best results bread, good! Except for one secret technique to 450°F the oven, and bake until golden,... Preheated baking sheet and cook until the cheese is on the outside for the best meltiness additional. A single layer in melted butter on baking sheet make sure the cheese starts to melt, about 5.... Cheese sandwiches is almost a no-brainer, except for one secret technique position rimmed baking sheet a. Place on the outside for the best results the sandwiches mid-bake cheese & meat on of! 7 minutes 6 slices, mayo … Use an oven to crisp your bread without the butter ’. Light mayo on the outside for the best results the best results or just to try different... 7 minutes bread butter side down on a cookie sheet or cheese include. Trial and error then top with second slice butter side down on grilled cheese in oven cookie sheet … Use an oven crisp! Crispy, the cheese is on the bake setting because it ’ s very much possible some! New taste bread, a good helping of butter and ( obviously ) cheese bake at 425°F cheese!